package plugins import ( "testing" "github.com/stretchr/testify/assert" "gitlab.com/demodesk/neko/server/pkg/types" ) func Test_deps_addPlugin(t *testing.T) { type args struct { p []types.Plugin } tests := []struct { name string args args want map[string]*dependency skipRun bool wantErr1 bool wantErr2 bool }{ { name: "three plugins - no dependencies", args: args{ p: []types.Plugin{ &dummyPlugin{name: "first"}, &dummyPlugin{name: "second"}, &dummyPlugin{name: "third"}, }, }, want: map[string]*dependency{ "first": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "first", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, "second": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "second", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, "third": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "third", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, }, }, { name: "three plugins - one dependency", args: args{ p: []types.Plugin{ &dummyPlugin{name: "third", dep: []string{"second"}}, &dummyPlugin{name: "first"}, &dummyPlugin{name: "second"}, }, }, want: map[string]*dependency{ "first": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "first", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, "second": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "second", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, "third": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "third", dep: []string{"second"}, idx: 1}, invoked: true, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "second", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, }, }, }, }, { name: "three plugins - one double dependency", args: args{ p: []types.Plugin{ &dummyPlugin{name: "third", dep: []string{"first", "second"}}, &dummyPlugin{name: "first"}, &dummyPlugin{name: "second"}, }, }, want: map[string]*dependency{ "first": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "first", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, "second": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "second", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, "third": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "third", dep: []string{"first", "second"}, idx: 1}, invoked: true, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "first", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "second", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, }, }, }, }, { name: "three plugins - two dependencies", args: args{ p: []types.Plugin{ &dummyPlugin{name: "third", dep: []string{"first"}}, &dummyPlugin{name: "first"}, &dummyPlugin{name: "second", dep: []string{"first"}}, }, }, want: map[string]*dependency{ "first": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "first"}, invoked: false, dependsOn: nil, }, "third": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "third", dep: []string{"first"}}, invoked: false, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "first"}, invoked: false, dependsOn: nil, }, }, }, "second": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "second", dep: []string{"first"}}, invoked: false, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "first"}, invoked: false, dependsOn: nil, }, }, }, }, skipRun: true, }, { name: "three plugins - three dependencies", args: args{ p: []types.Plugin{ &dummyPlugin{name: "third", dep: []string{"second"}}, &dummyPlugin{name: "first"}, &dummyPlugin{name: "second", dep: []string{"first"}}, }, }, want: map[string]*dependency{ "first": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "first", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, "second": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "second", dep: []string{"first"}, idx: 1}, invoked: true, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "first", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, }, }, "third": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "third", dep: []string{"second"}, idx: 2}, invoked: true, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "second", dep: []string{"first"}, idx: 1}, invoked: true, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "first", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, }, }, }, }, }, }, { name: "four plugins - added in reverse order, with dependencies", args: args{ p: []types.Plugin{ &dummyPlugin{name: "forth", dep: []string{"third"}}, &dummyPlugin{name: "third", dep: []string{"second"}}, &dummyPlugin{name: "second", dep: []string{"first"}}, &dummyPlugin{name: "first"}, }, }, want: map[string]*dependency{ "first": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "first", idx: 0}, invoked: false, dependsOn: nil, }, "second": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "second", dep: []string{"first"}, idx: 0}, invoked: false, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "first", idx: 0}, invoked: false, dependsOn: nil, }, }, }, "third": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "third", dep: []string{"second"}, idx: 0}, invoked: false, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "second", dep: []string{"first"}, idx: 0}, invoked: false, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "first", idx: 0}, invoked: false, dependsOn: nil, }, }, }, }, }, "forth": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "forth", dep: []string{"third"}, idx: 0}, invoked: false, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "third", dep: []string{"second"}, idx: 0}, invoked: false, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "second", dep: []string{"first"}, idx: 0}, invoked: false, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "first", idx: 0}, invoked: false, dependsOn: nil, }, }, }, }, }, }, }, }, skipRun: true, }, { name: "four plugins - two double dependencies", args: args{ p: []types.Plugin{ &dummyPlugin{name: "forth", dep: []string{"first", "third"}}, &dummyPlugin{name: "third", dep: []string{"first", "second"}}, &dummyPlugin{name: "second"}, &dummyPlugin{name: "first"}, }, }, want: map[string]*dependency{ "first": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "first", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, "second": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "second", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, "third": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "third", dep: []string{"first", "second"}, idx: 1}, invoked: true, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "first", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "second", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, }, }, "forth": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "forth", dep: []string{"first", "third"}, idx: 2}, invoked: true, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "first", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "third", dep: []string{"first", "second"}, idx: 1}, invoked: true, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "first", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "second", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, }, }, }, }, }, }, { // So, when we have plugin A in the list and want to add plugin C we can't determine the proper order without // resolving their direct dependiencies first: // // Can be C->D->A->B if D depends on A // // So to do it properly I would imagine tht we need to resolve all direct dependiencies first and build multiple lists: // // i.e. A->B->C D F->G // // and then join these lists in any order. name: "add indirect dependency CDAB", args: args{ p: []types.Plugin{ &dummyPlugin{name: "A", dep: []string{"B"}}, &dummyPlugin{name: "C", dep: []string{"D"}}, &dummyPlugin{name: "B"}, &dummyPlugin{name: "D", dep: []string{"A"}}, }, }, want: map[string]*dependency{ "B": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "B", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, "A": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "A", dep: []string{"B"}, idx: 1}, invoked: true, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "B", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, }, }, "D": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "D", dep: []string{"A"}, idx: 2}, invoked: true, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "A", dep: []string{"B"}, idx: 1}, invoked: true, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "B", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, }, }, }, }, "C": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "C", dep: []string{"D"}, idx: 3}, invoked: true, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "D", dep: []string{"A"}, idx: 2}, invoked: true, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "A", dep: []string{"B"}, idx: 1}, invoked: true, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "B", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, }, }, }, }, }, }, }, }, { // So, when we have plugin A in the list and want to add plugin C we can't determine the proper order without // resolving their direct dependiencies first: // // Can be A->B->C->D (in this test) if B depends on C // // So to do it properly I would imagine tht we need to resolve all direct dependiencies first and build multiple lists: // // i.e. A->B->C D F->G // // and then join these lists in any order. name: "add indirect dependency ABCD", args: args{ p: []types.Plugin{ &dummyPlugin{name: "C", dep: []string{"D"}}, &dummyPlugin{name: "D"}, &dummyPlugin{name: "B", dep: []string{"C"}}, &dummyPlugin{name: "A", dep: []string{"B"}}, }, }, want: map[string]*dependency{ "D": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "D", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, "C": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "C", dep: []string{"D"}, idx: 1}, invoked: true, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "D", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, }, }, "B": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "B", dep: []string{"C"}, idx: 2}, invoked: true, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "C", dep: []string{"D"}, idx: 1}, invoked: true, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "D", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, }, }, }, }, "A": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "A", dep: []string{"B"}, idx: 3}, invoked: true, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "B", dep: []string{"C"}, idx: 2}, invoked: true, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "C", dep: []string{"D"}, idx: 1}, invoked: true, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "D", idx: 0}, invoked: true, dependsOn: nil, }, }, }, }, }, }, }, }, }, { name: "add duplicate plugin", args: args{ p: []types.Plugin{ &dummyPlugin{name: "first"}, &dummyPlugin{name: "first"}, }, }, want: map[string]*dependency{ "first": {plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "first", idx: 0}, invoked: true}, }, wantErr1: true, }, { name: "cyclical dependency", args: args{ p: []types.Plugin{ &dummyPlugin{name: "first", dep: []string{"second"}}, &dummyPlugin{name: "second", dep: []string{"first"}}, }, }, want: map[string]*dependency{ "first": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "first", dep: []string{"second"}, idx: 1}, invoked: true, }, }, wantErr1: true, }, { name: "four plugins - cyclical transitive dependencies in reverse order", args: args{ p: []types.Plugin{ &dummyPlugin{name: "forth", dep: []string{"third"}}, &dummyPlugin{name: "third", dep: []string{"second"}}, &dummyPlugin{name: "second", dep: []string{"first"}}, &dummyPlugin{name: "first", dep: []string{"forth"}}, }, }, want: map[string]*dependency{ "second": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "second", dep: []string{"first"}, idx: 0}, invoked: false, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "first", dep: []string{"forth"}, idx: 0}, invoked: false, dependsOn: nil, }, }, }, "third": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "third", dep: []string{"second"}, idx: 0}, invoked: false, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "second", dep: []string{"first"}, idx: 0}, invoked: false, dependsOn: []*dependency{ { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "first", dep: []string{"forth"}, idx: 0}, invoked: false, dependsOn: nil, }, }, }, }, }, "forth": { plugin: &dummyPlugin{name: "forth", dep: []string{"third"}, idx: 0}, invoked: false, dependsOn: nil, }, }, wantErr1: true, skipRun: true, }, } for _, tt := range tests { t.Run(tt.name, func(t *testing.T) { d := &dependiencies{deps: make(map[string]*dependency)} var ( err error counter int ) for _, p := range tt.args.p { if !tt.skipRun { p.(*dummyPlugin).counter = &counter } if err = d.addPlugin(p); err != nil { break } } if err != nil != tt.wantErr1 { t.Errorf("dependiencies.addPlugin() error = %v, wantErr1 %v", err, tt.wantErr1) return } if !tt.skipRun { if err := d.start(types.PluginManagers{}); (err != nil) != tt.wantErr2 { t.Errorf("dependiencies.start() error = %v, wantErr1 %v", err, tt.wantErr2) } } assert.Equal(t, tt.want, d.deps) }) } } type dummyPlugin struct { name string dep []string idx int counter *int } func (d dummyPlugin) Name() string { return d.name } func (d dummyPlugin) DependsOn() []string { return d.dep } func (d dummyPlugin) Config() types.PluginConfig { return nil } func (d *dummyPlugin) Start(types.PluginManagers) error { if len(d.dep) > 0 { *d.counter++ d.idx = *d.counter } d.counter = nil return nil } func (d dummyPlugin) Shutdown() error { return nil }